Strong winds removed the large metal spire before it fell into the Langley First Baptist Church's courtyard which is surrounded by three walls from the church's sanctuary and Sunday school building.
Rev Ken Klingler told local station WRDW that it was a miracle it landed without causing damage to any building or their stained glass windows.
Pam Smith works at the church and decided to leave early when she saw a storm was brewing.
She discovered that the steeple fell shortly after she left when she got a call from her husband telling her it had fallen.
Incredible sight to see at the Langley First Baptist Church in Warrenville. This is the aftermath of a storm that blew the church steeple over last night. We're back here today giving you the latest on what church members say is "a miracle." Just look where it fell! @WRDW_WAGT pic.twitter.com/YHfCiprSkm
— Matt Kaufax (@MattKWRDW) August 7, 2018
"I just kept saying, 'oh my God' because he protected not only me but - he [also] protected everyone in the community," she said.
"I think it was a big miracle."
She added that the church had already received several calls from other churches and neighbours who offered to help support this clean-up needed.
Stay up to date with the latest news stories from a Christian perspective. Sign up to our daily newsletter and receive more stories like this straight to your inbox every morning.