The Virginia Supreme Court has reinstated a lawsuit accusing the West Point School Board of violating the rights of a high school teacher, Peter Vlaming, by firing him for refusing to use personal pronouns inconsistent with a student's sex.
Represented by religious freedom group Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), Vlaming, a Christian French teacher with nearly seven years of service, objected to using the student's pronouns.
Despite Vlaming's efforts to accommodate the student by using their preferred name and avoiding pronouns altogether, school officials insisted he use pronouns.
The Virginia Supreme Court upheld Vlaming's case, recognising that the father of four was terminated not for something he said, but for his principled refusal to express messages contradicting his beliefs.
ADF Senior Counsel Chris Schandevel, who argued on Vlaming's behalf, asserted that the teacher's dismissal violated the Virginia Constitution's commitment to protecting diversity of thought, speech, religion, and opinion. The court emphasised that without a compelling reason, no government could coerce citizens into endorsing ideological views conflicting with their sincerely held religious beliefs.
The court's opinion in Vlaming vs West Point School Board concluded that the board unlawfully attempted to force Vlaming to endorse the school's ideological perspectives on gender identity.
Shawn Voyles, part of the ADF Attorney Network, served as co-counsel, supporting Vlaming's right to uphold his convictions. The decision affirms the importance of safeguarding individuals' rights to adhere to their deeply held beliefs without facing punitive measures from government entities or educational institutions.