News by email Donate

Suggestions

World News

'He's not a prophet, just a man doing his best': Christian commentator defends Starmer in Mandelson vetting row

by Nayana Mena
2025-06-11T000000Z_1167650506_MT1NURPHO000YRP0K3_RTRMADP_3_LONDON-UK-PMQS-KIER-STARMER.JPG - Banner image
Image Credit: Reuters

A Christian commentator has defended Prime Minister Keir Starmer as he faced mounting pressure to resign over not being informed that his former ambassador to the United States, Peter Mandelson, had failed security vetting before being handed the job.

In conversation with Premier Christian News on Friday, Rev Andy Fitchet, a Methodist minister and vice-chair of Christians On The Left said: "I think he is absolutely right to stay in post.[...] I think it's astounding that we have a system which could withhold information from the Foreign Secretary and from the Prime Minister."

"I think accountability doesn't always mean resigning. I think sometimes it can mean staying the course, fixing the problems that are seen in front of us and putting them right," Fitchet added.

This came as Starmer said it was "staggering" that ‌he had not been told that former ambassador to the United ​States Peter Mandelson had ​failed his security vetting.

Fitchet, the former Labour councillor, said that Starmer couldn't have possibly known what he "wasn't told".

"He's not a prophet, he's just a man doing his best," he said.

He added: "Yes, absolutely, he bears ultra responsibility, but you can only bear responsibility for the things you know and the mistakes that you make with the information that you have."

Starmer, asked ⁠whether he was considering ​his position, replied that he was ​furious that he had not been told about the failure.

"That I ​wasn't told that Peter Mandelson ​had failed security vetting when he ‌was ⁠appointed is staggering," Starmer told reporters.

"Not only was I not told, no minister was told, ​and ​I'm absolutely ⁠furious about that."

He added: "What I intend to ​do is to go ​to ⁠parliament on Monday to set out all the relevant facts ⁠in ​true transparency so ​parliament has the full picture."

When asked how Christians should respond, Fitchet spoke about the importance of prayer.

"Praying for leaders generously is really helpful. Praying for them to have wisdom in decisions that they make, praying for them to have integrity in the way they act and resilience as well."

He concluded: "The Prime Minister holds a hugely heavy burden in the role that he does. So praying for strength and grace in that would be really important."

News you can believe in. Stand with Premier Christian News today.

Your gift today ensures that Premier Christian News can press forward in strength, reaching more people with biblical truth and shaping the future of Christian thought. It’s more than just a donation—it’s an investment in renewed minds and transformed lives. 

Without continued support, the ability to create and distribute resources that strengthen faith and equip the church will be compromised. But with your help, we can grow deeper, stand firmer, and shine brighter in the culture.

Your support today is critical.

Support Us
Continue the conversation on our Facebook page

Related Articles

Sign up to our newsletter to stay informed with news from a Christian perspective.

News by email

Connect

Donate

Donate