News by email Donate

Suggestions

ice was here x banner.JPG
X
ice was here x.JPG
X
USA News

Away from the manger: Church sparks controversy with ICE nativity scene

by Anna Rees Green

A Massachusetts church has sparked debate with its controversial ‘ICE’ nativity display.

Instead of figures from the Christmas scene, the manger and stable remain empty, as a sign reads: “ICE was here”.

Below it, another sign says: “The Holy Family is safe in The Sanctuary of our Church. If you see ICE please call LUCE,” in reference to the Immigration Justice Network of Massachusetts.

The church’s priest, Rev Stephen Josoma, said the sign was his idea.

 St. Susanna Parish in Dedham, via Facebook

Critics labelled the scene as a “crackpot publicity stunt”, while others claimed he was “exploiting the Holy Family” for a political agenda.

Rev Josoma was adamant that the display tells an important message.

“This is a stance I hope all churches would take,” he told Fox News. “What we celebrate at Christmas is the peace that Christ brought into the world… [the Christmas message] is right here, right now.”

A 67-year-old parishioner, Marjorie Yie, said the scene highlights the vulnerability of  Christ coming to earth.

“Jesus was a refugee,” she told the Boston Globe. “He had to flee his native country, his parents took him because they were worried he would be killed.”

It is not the first time Saint Susanna parish has sparked discussion; a previous scene saw the Baby Jesus placed in a cage, in reference to the detaining of children at the US-Mexico border.

Rev Josoma hoped that instead of controversy, the nativity would spark compassion and conversations around loving one’s neighbour.

News you can believe in. Stand with Premier Christian News today.

Your gift today ensures that Premier Christian News can press forward in strength, reaching more people with biblical truth and shaping the future of Christian thought. It’s more than just a donation—it’s an investment in renewed minds and transformed lives. 

Without continued support, the ability to create and distribute resources that strengthen faith and equip the church will be compromised. But with your help, we can grow deeper, stand firmer, and shine brighter in the culture.

Your support today is critical.

Support Us
Continue the conversation on our Facebook page

Related Articles

Sign up to our newsletter to stay informed with news from a Christian perspective.

News by email

Connect

Donate

Donate